How to curate a college list

Thoughts from Undergraduate Admissions Executive Director Robert Penman

Blogs
A student in a white button-down shirt, works on their iPad outside at a table in the UC Davis Redwood Grove.
Make your college list work for you. (Fred Greaves/UC Davis)

Dear students,

Recently, I came across a story about a student who applied and gained admission to over 100 colleges last fall. While this is an impressive feat, this approach to college applications is not one I recommend. It’s common to think that you need to apply to as many schools as possible to increase your chances of an acceptance. However, this approach often overwhelms and affects the quality of your applications.

Apply to schools that fit you and your unique goals.

As we kick off a new school year and admissions cycle, I share my thoughts on how to create a college application list. Here are my three key tips: 

  1. Consider the environment and other factors. 

Each year, without fail, I receive messages from some admitted students who thank me for the opportunity to study at UC Davis. However, they ultimately decline our offer because we don’t offer the programs they want to study. When you (and your family) take the time to self-reflect (and research) about what matters, you save $80 or so dollars on application fees. Ask yourself what kind of college experience you want. How far from home do you want to go? What majors interest you? Consider factors like academics, campus community, size, location and even cost. It’s also important to talk openly with your family about what’s affordable and what financial aid makes possible. 

  1. Maintain realistic expectations. 

The United States contains approximately 4,000 colleges and universities. Roughly 25 of them admit less than 10% of students per year. Stretch yourself but note where you thrive academically and personally. Apply to schools with broad ranges of selectivity that you would absolutely attend if admitted. A balanced list includes a mix of schools — some that are a bit of a reach and some with a stronger chance. Remember, it’s not about the perceived prestige of the school, but how well it fits your goals and preferences.

  1. Understand that there is a place for you.

The college admissions process intimidates many students, especially with so much focus on selectivity. Not all schools are highly competitive. The average admission rate across University of California, or UC, campuses is about 64% for California residents but each one varies widely in selectivity, and some majors are more selective than others. The UC Davis acceptance rate for fall 2024 is 42.1% for first-year and 58.7% for transfer students. At UC Santa Barbara, it’s lower and at UC Santa Cruz, it’s higher. Don’t feel discouraged when you look at a number — there is a place for you. 

Each application represents a potential path. When you create your college application list, focus on quality over quantity. A well-curated list reflects what you want and fits your values and future goals. 

Good luck as you take the next step in your academic journey. You got this!

From, 
Robert Penman 
Executive Director, UC Davis Undergraduate Admissions  

Primary Category

Tags